Do Knife Firms Lie About Their Metal?

It’s a standard concern amongst knife collectors. You spend simply over $150 (for those who’re fortunate) on a model new knife with the most recent metal, solely to second guess whether or not it’s the metal you paid for.

It might be as a result of the metal is beginning to rust in some spots, dulls faster than you count on, or isn’t as powerful as you thought it must be.

That’s while you begin to ask your self: do knife corporations mislabel or lie about the kind of metal they’re utilizing?

The reality is that generally they do.

Sure, Some Manufacturers Deliberately Mislabel Metal

I made a decision to put in writing this submit after watching a video knifemaker and former Chilly Metal collaborator Andrew Demko did on a YouTube channel in November 2020.

When the interviewer talked about that individuals had been ambivalent about the usage of AUS10A metal in one in all Chilly Metal’s knives, Demko mentioned that the rationale sure metal will get a nasty popularity is as a result of some knife corporations are deliberately passing off decrease finish metal like AUS6A for AUS8A.

Try the related portion from 28:58 to 29:40:

It was fairly shocking to listen to Demko say that it was a truth and one thing he’s seen firsthand. Demko didn’t point out the title of the businesses that do it, so we don’t know the culprits. It was good to listen to that Lynn Thompson, the previous president of Chilly Metal, didn’t partake within the fraud.

Examples of Firms Mislabeling Steels

Earlier than going via some examples of knife manufacturers utilizing metal completely different than marketed, I ought to be aware that it’s not at all times intentional. There could also be instances the place the provider despatched the unsuitable metal or it was merely a nasty batch. Not all the businesses who’ve mislabeled metal are dangerous or out to rip-off folks.

Bark River Knives & CPM154/A2 Metal

In 2017, one of our favorite knife YouTubers — Pete from Cedric & Ada Gear and Outdoors — performed a rust-resistance check on the Bark River JX6 in CPM 154. He discovered the knife was unusually rusty for a metal that’s purported to have fairly good corrosion-resistance.

Right here is the preliminary check:

After Pete went backwards and forwards with Bark River, it looks like they admitted it was a mislabeling of the knife. Since Bark River did promote the knife in A2 metal and CPM 154 metal, I believe it was more than likely a easy error in labeling the knife moderately than an effort to rip-off folks.

Nonetheless, I used to be not capable of finding out whether or not Bark River recalled the knives or refunded folks for the error.

Subsequent checks of Bark River merchandise have all appeared to match up with the metal.

CRKT & the S30V Hootenanny

In 2016, CRKT underwent an analogous controversy when it bought an unique model of Ken Onion’s terribly named Hootenanny with S30V metal via a supplier. The standard version makes use of 8Cr13Mov chrome steel.

On the time, CRKT was not recognized for utilizing larger high quality steels, so folks had been pumped to get an upgraded model of any CRKT knife.

Issues rapidly turned bitter when one member of BladeForums seen the knife staining rapidly after slicing an apple.

After tons of individuals seen the identical difficulty and needed solutions, CRKT responded with an announcement:

We’re conscious of the issue with the blade metal. We’ve taken speedy actions and the load of the difficulty shouldn’t be misplaced on us.

An impartial third occasion lab check has confirmed that the metal shouldn’t be S30V. We had been dissatisfied within the final result of the check and we’re at the moment revisiting not solely {our relationships}, additionally our personal processes.

We’ve got taken the next steps to make sure that historical past doesn’t repeat itself:
· Re-confirming our provider certifications.
· Growing an improved High quality Assurance course of for all CRKT merchandise.

We care about high quality right here at Columbia River Knife & Instrument and integrity is mission vital to how we’ve got chosen to do enterprise. We acknowledge that points like these threaten that core attribute of who we’re.

Douglas Flagg
VP Gross sales & Advertising and marketing

CRKT and the supplier instantly requested a return of the knives for a full refund.

Right here’s a video summarizing the drama:

It was good of them to request returns, however CRKT did take successful for just a few years after that. They haven’t had that difficulty since so far as anybody can inform.

YouTuber Has Knives Examined

Over the course of three years, YouTuber LuvThemKnives had lots of of knives despatched to a lab to seek out out whether or not precise metal matched with the marketed metal.

Though that is anecdotal, the outcomes had been fairly attention-grabbing. As you would possibly count on, the principle manufacturers like Spyderco, Benchmade, Chilly Metal, CRKT, CIVIVI, and others all matched  up.

It was a number of the lesser recognized or knockoff manufacturers that didn’t appear to match up correctly. He assembled the full list of tested knives in a Google spreadsheet to your viewing pleasure.

Manufacturers like Eafengrow, Y-Begin, Fura, and Komoran gave the impression to be the most important offenders in these checks. Like I mentioned, it’s very attainable these had been merely dangerous batches or unintentional, however you would possibly wish to watch out shopping for these knives.

Then, in fact, any clones or counterfeits had been additionally mislabeling their steels, however you could possibly most likely already guess that.

The way to Inform If Knife Metal is Legit

The age-old query is inform if one thing is actual or not.

For counterfeits, it may be fairly laborious to inform if one thing is actual or not, however we’ve got just a few suggestions you’ll be able to observe in our submit on how to tell if your knife is a counterfeit.

If in case you have an actual knife and wish to know whether or not the metal marketed is definitely the metal to procure, then it turns into loads harder.

The best means is to do your individual dwelling check. For instance, you’ll be able to see whether or not a knife is definitely chrome steel by conducting a rust check like these completed by Pete from Cedric & Ada. After all, this requires some information of how the metal ought to carry out and gained’t essentially detect the distinction in tiers of stainless steels.

One among Pete from Cedric & Ada Gear and Outside experiments.

Even when the efficiency doesn’t match up, it might be the results of poor warmth therapy or high quality management.

For those who actually wish to know, you’ll be able to ship your knife to a lab to see the alloy percentages used within the metal, however except you recognize somebody, it is perhaps laborious or expensive to do.

Our greatest recommendation is to purchase knives from respected manufacturers via respected sellers.

Sadly, nothing in life is ever sure, apart from taxes and dying.

Source link

Join Our Mailing List!

Get the best deals in tactical gear and training to your inbox daily!